“Should we work with one big influencer or lots of small ones?” is one of the first questions every brand asks us. The answer depends on what you need the campaign to do, but for most DTC brands starting out, it's more smaller creators.
The influencer tiers
There's no official definition, and different agencies draw the lines differently. These are the commonly used ranges:
| Tier | Followers |
|---|---|
| Nano | 1,000 to 10,000 |
| Micro | 10,000 to 100,000 |
| Mid-tier | 100,000 to 500,000 |
| Macro | 500,000 to 1 million |
| Mega | 1 million or more |
Why smaller creators often win
- Closer audiences. Smaller creators usually have higher engagement rates, because their followers feel closer to them. A recommendation lands more like advice from a friend.
- Sharper niches. A 20,000-follower creator who only posts about running shoes reaches exactly the right people. A celebrity reaches everyone, including millions who'll never buy.
- You learn more. Ten creators give you ten audiences, angles and formats to compare. One creator gives you one result and no way to tell why.
- Less risk. If one post underperforms, it's a small part of the campaign, not the whole budget.
When bigger creators make sense
Macro and mega creators are worth it when reach is the goal: a major launch moment, a brand that already converts well and needs scale, or a category where one trusted face changes perception. They work best on top of a base of smaller creators, not instead of one.
How to compare creators of different sizes
Don't compare follower counts. Compare what you actually get: cost per view from their recent posts (our influencer CPM calculator lines quotes up side by side), engagement rate worked out the same way for each creator (our engagement rate calculator does this), and how closely their audience matches your customer. More on judging quotes in how much do influencers charge.
The nano end: seeding
At the nano end, paying every creator gets expensive fast, and that's where gifting comes in. Sending product to hundreds of small creators with no guaranteed post can deliver more total reach than one paid macro post. Here's how product seeding works, and why volume beats virality.








